Managed to get hold of AmResearch write-up on Silver Bird.
Here are some of the points mentioned..
- Results analysis
Below expectations. Silver Bird Group Bhd’s (“Silver Bird”) net profit for 1QFY06 of RM1.943m equalled only 6.5% of our FY06 net profit forecast of RM19.7m. We under-estimated the extent of losses from its operations in Singapore, which ballooned from a loss off RM1.76m in 4QFY05 to RM2.88m in 1QFY06.
Only 6.5% of full-year net profit forecast? Management had previously indicated that it was confident of breaking even before the end of FY06. Taking this into consideration, we expected losses in the first half of the FY06 and a profit in the second half of the year. Based on the reported loss from its Singapore operations in 1QFY06, however, we are now increasing the expected losses from its Singapore operations from just over RM2m for the year to about RM8.6m. This will revise our earnings forecast for FY06 by nearly 20% to RM15.8m.
Borrowings reduced significantly, and still a priority. Management was keen to point out that short-term borrowings had declined by a full RM10m from RM85m in the previous quarter. Silver Bird has been working hard to clean up its balance sheet in the light of an increasing interest rate environment which has increased the cost of its capital. In addition, both trade receivables and trade payables both declined significantly in 1QFY06 - implying a greater efficiency in collection of debts on the one hand and a better control on costs on the other, according to Management.
Cashflow turns positive. The net impact of the above is a turnaround from a net debt position of RM9.1m at the end of 4QFY05 and a net cash position of RM5.0m at the end of 1QFY06. This swing of RM14m is impressive. We believe that this stands Silver Bird in good stead as it actively explores ways to reduce gearing as well as to promote efficiency, all whilst growing its profitability in Malaysia and gaining scale in Singa-pore.
With strong prospects of a turaround of sorts in as early as this 2QFY06, we are recommending no change in our HOLD call for now, although its share price may fall sharply on the back of the lower than expected 1QFY06 earnings.
And AmResearch concludes that ..
- Valuation and Recommendation
Given the likely profit contribution from its Singapore venture in FY07, bullish investors may not currently believe that SBG should be valued at less than 8.5x FY06 PER. This would imply a price target of RM0.62 based on our revised EPS of 73 sen in FY06. This excludes the dilutive effect of the 105m warrants still in the market though, as its current trading price of RM0.14 and conversion price of RM0.80 makes it unlikely to see many warrants being converted to Silver Bird shares in the next two to three years at the least.
We reiterate our caution, though that there is a significant possibility of sustained elling pressure in the aftermath – should observers fail to absorb the turnaround in its overseas operations that Management is confident of seeing in the last quarter of FY06, at the latest.
Oh... what I find so strange is that after their over whelming bullish write-up on Aug 2005, OSK did not have a follow-up article on Silver Bird.
I really wonder why... perhaps that little birdie just flew up, up and awayyyyyyy....
:p
nm,
ReplyDeletethis osk hoh.... I think the treatment meeted out to Birdie is similar to its MMM last 2 years.
When it failed to hit its projection, they just let it died a natural way.
Pura pura they never make this call. In this sense Amsecurities is superior as they will notify us that it will cease coverage of certain securities when it failed to satisfy their requirement like ACPI.
Exactly dude!
ReplyDeleteAnd this was why I blogged on it. Do you remember the blog posting I made on Timberwell?
And guess what? That incredible Timberwell file could not be found again on their site...
luckily.. as u know.. i had saved a copy of their write-up!
hhc,
ReplyDeleteoh dat timberwell blog posting can be found here...
http://whereiszemoola.blogspot.com//2006/03/disclaimers-continued.html
or look under Map of Mumblings .. under the blog title "Disclaimers Continued.."
nm,
ReplyDeleteThis is the sad stage of affairs in BSKL. I think most of the analysts are not up to standards. The same thing also applied to US as most of the fresh analys will be grinded thru as junior analyst for a few years to be comform to their internal modus operandi.
I think we have to keep this in mind
" Those brokerage house has to jaga their inst client and their unit trust operation. So they can only be allowed to be more bullish than bearish on securities. They wont risk their bread and butter for the sake of investing public, will they?"
Another off topic, just found out that Farmbest got join venture with Mobif in IT stuff. What has chicken got to do with IT?? Rearing chicken requires local network or internet keh???
One more topic, just read thru risk profile of Jadi Imaging IPO on 2nd board handled by RHB. Do u know how much share they are going to issue...
172,000,000 Share with a paid up capital of 450,000,000 share in RM0.1 par value.
Oh my gosh. But its market cap is only RM85M.Rhb has definitely goes against the crowd where they try to limit the supply in order to push the price higher. I wonder how RHB is going to achieve this with major shareholder only holding 54% and mostly thru nominee comp.
Just my 2 sen
Ahh.. reminds me of Ryhtmn a couple years ago... and to a certain extent the fiasco over Hytrax Oil..
ReplyDeletethis is why...
we, the minoriteis, we need to be HEARD!!!!!!