Showing posts with label MAS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MAS. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

Local Media Coverage On MAS Earnings Announcement

Since I had posted on how the local media had glorified IOI's earnings by stating its net earnings jumped a whopping 15x in the posting WOW! Did IOI Net Profit Increased 15-Fold?, it's only fair I should write a bit on MAS earnings announcement coverage.

On the Edge Financial Daily:
MAS posts RM310m net profit in 1Q


  • KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia Airlines Bhd (MAS) posted a net profit of RM310.05 million for the first quarter ended March 31, 2010 from a net loss of RM698.55 million a year earlier.

    It said on Monday, May 17 revenue was higher at RM3.30 billion from RM2.72 billion previously while earnings per share was 10.64 sen from loss per share of 34.02 sen.

    Its operating profit was RM289.5 million, a contrast from an operating loss of RM141.1 million a year ago, due to an increase in other operating income as a result of A380 compensation as well as improvement in passenger and cargo traffic demand.

    It saw derivative gain from fuel hedging contracts rise to RM56.7 million from a derivative loss of RM557 million a year ago.

Ok.. it has a derivative gain of rm56.7 million...

On AFP..

  • May 17, 2010, 7.27 pm

    Malaysia Airlines swings to Q1 profit

    KUALA LUMPUR - Malaysia Airlines said on Monday it had made a profit in the first quarter due to compensation received from Airbus and an increase in traffic, but remained cautious on the outlook for the year.

    The national carrier said net profits stood at RM310 million (US$96 million) in the three months to the end of March compared with a net loss of RM699 million in the same period last year.

    Revenue increased by 21 per cent to RM3.3 billion from RM2.7 million a year earlier as global travel was boosted by the economic recovery.

    Traffic increased by 29 per cent in the first quarter.

    Managing director and chief executive Azmil Zahruddin said it had been an 'encouraging' quarter.

    'Both passenger and cargo business showed strong growth, boosted by the economic recovery, and our swift response in capitalising on the increase in demand,' he told a news conference.

    Mr Azmil said profits were boosted by a RM329 million payment by Airbus that was partial compensation for a delay delivering the airline's first A380 superjumbo - originally due in 2007.

    Otherwise, the company would have suffered a loss, he said.

    The airline is now due to receive the first of six of the double-decker planes in late 2011 and expects further compensation from the European aircraft maker.

    Growth also suffered from a rise in the price of jet fuel by 55 per cent to US$85 a barrel. This led to an overall hike in the company's fuel costs of 42 per cent to RM1.01 billion.

    'It is still a challenging year for 2010,' said Mr Azmil. He added however: 'We believe we are very well positioned. We have seen strong growth in the Asia-Pacific region - we want to capitalise on that.'

    He said disruption of air traffic caused by a volcano in Iceland last month had cost Malaysia Airlines RM15 million. This was due to loss of sales, idling of aircraft and extra flights mounted to send home stranded passengers.

    Malaysia Airlines returned to the black in the fourth quarter of 2009, with net profits of RM610 million due to lower operation and fuel costs, as well as a rebound in cargo business. -- AFP

WOW! MAS made some tidy profit of rm 329 million from partial compensation from Airbus for late delivery. ( Life is good. :P)

On Bernama: MAS Returns To Black With Q1 Pre-Tax Profit Of RM320.25 Million

  • PETALING JAYA, May 17 (Bernama) -- Malaysia Airlines (MAS) returned to the black with a pre-tax profit of RM320.25 million for its first quarter ended March 31, 2010, from a loss of RM709.5 million in the same period last year.

    Revenue rose to RM3.301 billion from RM2.722 billion previously, the national carrier said Monday.

    MAS also said that it will take delivery of the B737-800, the largest plane in the world, in the fourth quarter of this year after several delays earlier.

    The airline posted a net profit of RM310 million, a swing of more than RM1 billion from the RM699 million net loss previously.

    MAS managing director and chief executive officer Tengku Datuk Azmil Zahruddin told a press conference that both passenger and cargo business showed strong growth in the first quarter, boosted by the economic recovery and its swift response in capitalising on the increase in demand.

    Its operating profit was at RM290 million, which included compensation for the delayed delivery of the A380 super jumbo aircraft, while operating profit was up RM431 million compared to the first quarter last year. The first quarter also saw a continuous strong growth in the cargo business as MASkargo's business traffic saw an upswing of 31 per cent.

    Cargo revenue rose 53 per cent to RM456 million from RM298 million previously.

    Tengku Azmil said MAS' focus for the year would be strengthen its balance sheet and yields, and enhance brand loyalty.

    "As part of its extensive fleet renewal programme, MAS will also take delivery of its first Boeing 737-800 aircraft in the fourth quarter this year," he said.

    "For 2010, the operating profit target is RM100 million to RM325 million," he added.

Hmm.. Bernama version does not explain how much was the compensation (rm 329 million) and neither does it talk about the derivative gain of rm56.7 million. And it omitted the statement from Tenku Azmil saying that "Otherwise, the company would have suffered a loss"

On Business Times.

  • Malaysia Airlines flies back into the black

    By Zaidi Isham Ismail Published: 2010/05/18

    Malaysia Airlines (MAS) (3786)has returned to profitability with a net profit of RM310 million in the first quarter ended March 31 2010, helped mainly by a RM320 million compensation from Airbus
    .

    The national carrier made a net loss of almost RM700 million in the same quarter a year ago.

    Airbus, the European aircraft maker, was to have delivered six A380s, the world's largest passenger plane, to MAS in 2007, which has been delayed until next year.

    MAS' first quarter revenue rose 21 per cent to RM3.3 billion from RM2.7 billion a year ago as economic recovery boosted global travel.

    Managing director Tengku Datuk Azmil Zahruddin said the year ahead would be challenging because of Iceland's volcanic ash clouds disrupting air traffic in Europe again, forcing some airports to close their airspace.
    "During the first ash cloud disruption, MAS made RM15 million losses, such as paying for aircraft holding cost at airports, hotels, loss of sales and clearing the backlog of passengers.

    "But I am optimistic that MAS will see continuous growth in the year ahead based on our encouraging first quarter during which both passenger and cargo business showed strong traffic loads of 75 per cent," Tengku Azmil told reporters at MAS' headquarters and training academy in Selangor yesterday.

    The stronger ringgit will also help the airline save on costs of fuel, spare parts and aircraft purchase, which are all transacted in US dollars.

    The first quarter also saw continued growth in its cargo business. MASkargo traffic saw an upswing of 31 per cent, lifting revenue 53 per cent to RM458 million from RM298 million.

    Tengku Azmil's optimism also stemmed from MAS' completed rights issue, which raised close to RM3.2 billion and boosted shareholders' equity to RM3.7 billion.

On Star Business: MAS Q1 net profit of RM310m due to delay in A380 delivery

  • Tuesday May 18, 2010
    MAS Q1 net profit of RM310m due to delay in A380 delivery
    By LEONG HUNG YEE

    Compensation boost for MAS

    PETALING JAYA: Malaysia Airlines (MAS) posted a net profit of RM310mil, or 10.64 sen per share, for the first quarter ended March 31, thanks to the significant compensation of RM329mil from Airbus SAS for the delay of A380 delivery.

    The national carrier had ordered six A380s, delivery of which had been delayed for the third time.

    Airbus was initially scheduled to start delivering the A380s in January 2007 but it was postponed to January 2011 following delays in the aircraft maker's programme. This was again deferred to August 2011.

    “The compensation is from previous delays and there will be further compensation as per the contractual agreement,” managing director/chief executive officer Tengku Datuk Azmil Zahruddin said at a briefing to announce its results yesterday.

    However, he did not reveal any figures for its further compensation.

    For the quarter under review, the carrier's pre-tax profit increased to RM320.2mil from a pre-tax loss of RM709.5mil on a 21% rise in turnover to RM3.3bil. MAS posted an operating profit of RM289.5mil for the quarter against an operating loss of RM141mil a year ago.

    To a question, Tengku Azmil said the group would be in a “slight red,”
    or a net loss of about RM39mil if not for the compensation from Airbus.

    However, he said, due to the higher fuel prices, MAS' fuel expenditure increased by 42%, or about RM300mil, to RM1.01bil against RM713mil last year.

    “Although our non-fuel expenditure has decreased 7%, it does not compensate for the steep increase in fuel cost,” he said, adding that fuel price volatility would be one of the industry's main challenges this year.

    MAS hedged 60% and 40% of its fuel requirement for 2010 and 2011 respectively at US$100 per barrel.

    The flag carrier made a derivative gain of RM56.7mil from fuel hedging for the quarter against a loss of RM557mil a year ago.

    During the quarter, MAS' traffic increased by 29% while its load factor stood at 74.8%. Its revenue per available seat km increased by 5% to 17.4 sen.

    Its results were also boosted by the strong performance from its cargo operations. “MASKargo has also been swift to respond to the increase in cargo demand which rebounded in the fourth quarter of 2009. The increase in traffic and revenue led to a 16% increase in yield to 79.5 sen,” Tengku Azmil said, adding that the overall load for cargo operations increased by 13.6 percentage points to 77.6%.

    “It has been an encouraging quarter. Both passenger and cargo business showed strong growth, boosted by the economic recovery, and our swift response in capitalising on the increase in demand.”

    He said the first and second quarters were typically its weakest but MAS managed to maintain its performance.

    To a question, Tengku Azmil said MAS was evaluating the best way to optimise its B737-400 planes, including allowing Firefly to use its fleet as it embarked on its fleet renewal programme.

    “We have not made any decision. It's always possible,” he said.

    “The outlook for the second quarter remains challenging. Oil prices continue to be volatile given the uncertainty in demand and supply and volatility of the US dollar,” MAS said in the notes accompanying its results.

    “MAS' focus for 2010 is to strengthen its balance sheet and yields and enhance brand loyalty. As part of its extensive fleet renewal programme, MAS will also take delivery of its first Boeing 737-800 aircraft in the fourth quarter this year.

    “For 2010, the operating profit target of the group is RM100mil to RM325mil, while the on-time performance target for the company is 84.7% to 87%,” MAS said.

    Analysts contacted generally were rather disappointed with MAS' latest quarterly results.

    An analyst said its profit all came from the RM329mil compensation from Airbus. He said it was below his expectation but airline earnings were erratic.

    Consensus estimates on Bloomberg expect MAS to post a net loss of RM50.3mil for the whole year while Thomson Reuters' average forecast expects a full-year net loss of more than RM30mil.

Well.. hat's off to Star Business on MAS earnings coverage. It was rather precise and most of the info is there for the investing public to read. The Edge Financial Daily usually does another update with a more detailed report later, so I would give them a benefit of a doubt. ( update 2 pm: Here is Edge Financial daily detailed artical: MAS stays cautious despite being profitable in 1Q )

AND THIS IS WHERE I NEED TO GIVE CREDIT. :D

The reporting on MAS earnings is certainly much better when compared to say Aug 2009.

Yes, do refer to this posting Fair Reporting On MAS?

Friday, August 07, 2009

Fair Reporting On MAS?

On the Edge Financial Daily: MAS posts RM875.5m net profit in 2Q

On the Sun:
MAS posts record RM676m net profit for Q2.

On Business Times:
MAS in the black

On Star Business:
Malaysia Airlines' Q2 profit highest ever despite economic crisis

Bottom line? Let me use this two lines from the Edge Financial Daily.

  • The group recorded an operating loss of RM420.8 million in 2Q compared with profit of RM62.0 million a year ago mainly due to lower operating revenue in line with the declining trend in global travel and cargo movements resulting from the current economic downturn.

    Derivative gain/(loss) consisted of realised gain/(loss) on settlement of hedging contracts during the quarter and fair value changes due to movement in mark-to-market (MTM) position on outstanding hedging contracts at June 30, 2009 as compared to Jan 1, 2009.

An operating loss of rm420.8 million!

And our local media is talking about MAS back in black and with RECORD profits even!

Ahh... fair reporting.

Monday, June 15, 2009

More On MAS Oil Hedging Losses

Posted on Saturday Comments On MAS Oil Hedging Losses.

Couple of interesting comments.


  • hhc1977 said...

    1)Competition is always good and i believe even though Msia might not have the market to support 2 domestic airlines (neither do Spore), we should not just let MAS to monopolize the market.
    2)Since they are both private entity (at least run as one), the onus to making profit lie solely on the boards to see this happen.
    3)The only problem is whatever loss they incur, gov should not bail out this MAS if thing go wrong. (Ego problem again..)
    4)I am truly amazed whether MAS is an airline or an oil trader considering the "loss" at its hedging (suuportive function) operation.
    5)Even though oil price is now higher than the level at March 31, but do shareholder in MAS really wants MAS to be an oil trader (if oil price held, the next Q result MAS might be cheered as good GLC turnaround and all the hooha this time will be history again).
    6)As for me, i will only invest MAS as an AIRLINE which does what an airline should do.
    7)Can we do a comparison between MAS, cathay and SIA on their respective hedging activities?

Here's another

  • Maverick said...

    Yes, agree, they did much too many contracts. If oil goes down again (I am bullish on oil, but it is certainly possibly it can go down, there are still lots and lots of big items in the global economy that can go terribly wrong), then the losses of MAS will be very real. Losing billions on "hedging" when profits are in the hundreds of millions doesnt make sense to me at all.

    The other thing I dont like is how they try to hide things. First of all I dont understand the delay in the results. Secondly they should have done mark-to-market more early (best was immediately after buying the contracts). Thirdly, what they did now is book a decent loss in this quarter (actually less than analysts expected: 1 billion was predicted) and the other hedging losses are hidden in restating the old accounts. That way it doesnt look too bad.

    When will companies learn, have seen so many companies burn their fingers on these contracts in a big way? The only ones I have ever seen making some money on it are well managed plantation companies, they sometimes have the foresight of selling (part of) their future production when they expect that the current price is high. Even they cant have it 100% right, but at least they seem to have it more often right than wrong. Other companies I only see making small profits, and then a huge loss erasing all profits so far.

On Business Times: MAS fuel-hedging strategy gets mixed reviews

  • ANALYSTS are mixed about whether Malaysia Airlines (MAS) (3786) is doing the right thing in its fuel contracts, but they agree that the outlook for the national carrier looks sombre.

    "I do not find the mark-to-market losses it posted all that worrying because, it is something that most companies will have to go through come 2010, and MAS did take some measures to mitigate its affects," Maybank Investment Bank senior analyst Khair Mirza told Business Times.

    "What I am more worried about is that the carrier does not seem to be reacting fast enough to passengers' needs. They are not doing enough.

    "With the second quarter being traditionally its weakest quarter, and the H1N1 flu gathering more intensity, it is hard to imagine the carrier making a profit (in the second quarter of 2009)," he added.
    Khair estimated that during the January-March period, MAS had lost 30 per cent of its passengers to its competitors.

    On Friday, MAS reported a net loss of RM695 million in its first quarter ended March 31 2009, versus a year-ago net profit, largely due to its fuel hedging contracts.

    Notwithstanding the RM640 million mark-to-market fuel hedging losses, the carrier posted RM138 million in operating loss.

    It also said it had spent some RM400 million to restructure its hedging contracts into 2011.

    Standard & Poor's Asian Equity Research analyst Shukor Yusof said MAS' mark-to-market losses is an indication of what to expect from the carrier in the coming months.

    For MAS to be a trend setter, he believes that it should take a more proactive approach in its fuel hedging strategies.

    "One of MAS' main problems is that it adopts a herd mentality when it comes to fuel hedges. There is no real vision and MAS is obviously afraid to take risks," Shukor said.

    The airline could still make a profit in the second quarter, though, albeit not an operational one, again due to the airline's new accounting standard.

    This is because just as how the airline saw a paper loss of RM640 million in the first quarter, it could see a paper gain of RM1.1 billion on fuel hedging if oil prices average US$66 a barrel in the second quarter.

    Meanwhile, in a reply to a local blog posting on Rocky's Bru on Saturday, MAS executive director and chief financial officer Tengku Azmil Zahruddin said any business in which its major cost item doubles to US$180 per barrel in six months, only to fall to US$40 per barrel in the next six months, must take steps to protect itself against such volatility.

    He added that because airlines typically sell seats six months into the future and sometimes even up to 340 days in advance, the need to hedge against the unpredictability of fuel price is critical.

    "As with other airlines which hedge, MAS only enters into long fuel hedges, where we are buying fuel, and do not speculate by selling short in the fuel market, as may be the case with certain low-cost carriers," Tengku Azmil said.

Friday, June 12, 2009

MAS Suffers A Whopping 640 Million In Fuel Hedging Losses!!!

Posted a couple of months back: And What About MAS Oil Hedges?

In that Star Business article..

  • The national carrier does not book any losses as it does not adopt the mark-to-market practice, which essentially means assigning a value to a position held in a financial instrument based on current market price.

And in today's earnings, MAS adopts the mark-to-market practice.

From the company earnings notes.
  • The Group recorded an operating loss for the quarter of RM137.9 million from a profit of RM66.3 million mainly due to a lower operating revenue in line with declining trend in global travel and cargo movements resulting from the current economic downturn. The Group recorded a loss after tax for the quarter of RM694.8 million from a profit of RM46.6 million after including derivative loss of RM557.0 million with the early adoption of FRS 139.

Thursday, March 05, 2009

And What About MAS Oil Hedges?

As pointed out by AhBeng in recent AirAsia discussions (see AirAsia Reported Massive Losses Again!!, Comments On AirAsia Exceptional Losses and Reply To Comments On AirAsia Exceptional Losses ) Malaysia Airlines (MAS) only announced its realised hedges and on Star Business today, the following article was published.

MAS stands to lose RM3bil in hedging costs

  • Thursday March 5, 2009
    MAS stands to lose RM3bil in hedging costs
    By YVONNE TAN

    PETALING JAYA: Malaysia Airlines (MAS) stands to chalk up close to RM3bil in hedging costs over the next two years while its competitor AirAsia Bhd enjoys the benefits of lower crude oil prices, analysts say.

    An analyst estimated that MAS was currently sitting on a collective paper loss of around RM2.8bil for financial year 2009 and 2010 as a result of its hedging activities.

    MAS has hedged 64% of its fuel requirements for financial year (FY) ending Dec 31 at US$100 per barrel and 40% of FY10 at US$95 per barrel while crude oil is hovering around US$40 per barrel. The analyst estimates MAS using up to 16 million barrels of crude oil per year.

    “It is paying higher for crude as it has locked positions at US$100 and US$95 a barrel whereas the current price is only around US$40 a barrel,’’ the analyst said.

    The national carrier does not book any losses as it does not adopt the mark-to-market practice, which essentially means assigning a value to a position held in a financial instrument based on current market price.

    Kenanga Research said MAS’ FY09 hedge price was much higher than the figure revealed last year, which was 53% of FY09 crude at US$83 per barrel.

    “We suspect that the increase in FY09 hedge price could be due to non-linearity and complexity of the hedging instruments involved. As there are more than 80 fuel hedge instruments available in the market, these complicated derivatives when combined might have an adverse effect should spot prices reach a certain threshold,” it said.

    While analysts have raised concerns about MAS’ pricing ability which could be handicapped by its fuel hedge, they are equally concerned about AirAsia’s associates’ longer term prospects as these continue to gush red ink.

    However, AirAsia said it is now free of hedging contracts but not without having immense pressure on its profits in the second half of 2008. But going forward, AirAsia is in a better spot as it is paying market prices.

    AirAsia posted hefty losses of RM425.7mil in its latest quarter from the unwinding of its fuel hedge and interest rate swaps positions, which resulted in its exceptional losses increasing to RM833.4mil for FY08.

    The low-cost carrier had been buying fuel at spot price since the fourth quarter of last year and would start “on a clean slate” where hedging was concerned, analysts said.

    Hedges are essentially derivatives which airlines use to lock in a fuel price in advance to protect themselves from price volatility.

    The airline industry was plagued by record crude prices, which influenced jet fuel prices in the first half of last year.

    “Airlines entered into their hedging arrangements when it seemed that oil prices would not see their limit and that is why MAS is still paying more than double the current price,” an analyst noted.

    The global economic crisis has since brought prices well below the forecasts made by airlines when they bought into their respective hedges.